A right discovered
Writing for the majority, Justice Antonin Scalia said an individual right to bear arms exists and is supported by "the historical narrative" both before and after the Second Amendment was adopted.Missouri political leaders hailed the decision. The St. Louis Post Dispatch reported:President Bush said: "I applaud the Supreme Court's historic decision today confirming what has always been clear in the Constitution: the Second Amendment protects an individual right to keep and bear firearms."
The victory for the pro-gun community was punctuated in Missouri on Thursday by Gov. Matt Blunt signing legislation to seal records of people with a permit to carry concealed weapons, to eliminate a waiting period for new residents with permits from other states and to protect gun ranges from local anti-noise ordinances.Of course, not everyone is happy. Already, the New York Sun is already fretting that felons will be allowed to carry guns.
Jeff Mardis, who was at Bull's Eye on Thursday for target practice, said he likes to hunt but has a different reason to own a handgun: "Protection is No. 1."
Pointing out that Washington remained a violent city despite the tight limit on handgun ownership, Mardis said, "The effect is you disarm honest citizens who might come to your aid."
We'll hear more of this kind of "sky-is-falling" rhetoric, but I doubt that an affirmation of a right that has existed since the founding of the country is going to make a difference. People will kill people no matter what. You can take away every gun; crazy people or evil people will find a different way to kill.But little attention has been paid to the effect that the court's decision could have on regulations defining which groups of people can be excluded from gun ownership.
"The Court might decide there are some classes of felons that ought to be treated differently from other classes of felons," a former solicitor general, Theodore Olson, said in an interview on Thursday about the prospect that the Supreme Court may eventually permit felons to own guns.
Crimes ranging from murder to writing a hot check can count as felonies. The felon-in-possession law applies to people convicted of state crimes as well as federal crimes.
